Making Treaty Implementation More Like Statutory Implementation

Authors

Jean Galbraith, University of Pennsylvania Carey Law SchoolFollow

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2017

Abstract

Both statutes and treaties are the “supreme law of the land,” and yet quite different practices have developed with respect to their implementation. For statutes, all three branches have embraced the development of administrative law, which allows the executive branch to translate broad statutory directives into enforceable obligations. But for treaties, there is a far more cumbersome process. Unless a treaty provision contains language that courts interpret to be directly enforceable, they will deem it to require implementing legislation from Congress. This Article explores and challenges the perplexing disparity between the administration of statutes and treaties. It shows that the conventional assumption that Congress must implement treaties that are not directly enforceable by courts stems from an unduly narrow historical perspective. Instead, largely forgotten nineteenth-century practice and cases reveal that the executive branch can implement treaties so as to make them enforceable in the courts. Drawing on this past practice, this Article argues that it is time to reconfigure the administration of treaties. In at least some circumstances, the executive branch should be able to translate treaty provisions into court-enforceable obligations in a manner comparable to the statutory context, including through rulemaking by administrative agencies. This approach is particularly desirable for multilateral regulatory treaties, which have come to play an increasingly important role in global governance.

Keywords

Constitutional law, foreign relations, legal history, separation of powers, Take Care clause, Medellín v. Texas, Foster v. Neilson, non-self-executing, enforceability, Basel Convention on Hazardous Waste, executive authority

Publication Title

Michigan Law Review

Publication Citation

115 Mich. L. Rev. 1309 (2017)

Repository Citation

Galbraith, Jean, "Making Treaty Implementation More Like Statutory Implementation" (2017). All Faculty Scholarship. 1761.
https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/faculty_scholarship/1761