Personhood theory is almost invariably cited as one of the primary theoretical bases for copyright. The conventional wisdom views creative works as the embodiment of their creator’s personality. This unique connection between authors and their works justifies giving authors property interests in the results of their creative efforts.
This Chapter argues that the conventional wisdom is too limited. It offers too narrow a vision of the ways that creativity can develop personality by focusing exclusively on the results of the creative process and ignoring the self-actualizing benefits of the creative process itself. German aesthetic theory broadens the understanding of the interactions between creativity and personality. Psychologists, aestheticians, and philosophers have underscored how originating creative works can play an important role in self-actualization. When combined with the insight creative works frequently borrow from the corpus of existing works, this insight provides a basis for this insight provides a basis for broadening fair use rights. Moreover, to the extent that works must be shared with audiences or a community of like-minded people in order to be meaningful, it arguably supports a right of dissemination.
The result is a theory that values the creative process for the process itself and not just for the artifacts it creates, takes the interests of follow-on authors seriously, and provides an affirmative theory of the public domain. The internal logic of this approach carries with it a number of limitations, specifically that any access rights be limited to uses that are noncommercial and educational and extend no farther than the amount needed to promote self-actualization.
Personhood, intellectual property, creative works, derivative works, right of access, right of dissemination, art, creative process, play, psychology, aesthetics, self-determination theory, capabilities theory, property, commerciality
Cambridge Handbook of Limitations and Exceptions in Copyright Law
Yoo, Christopher S., "Self-Actualization and the Need to Create as a Limit on Copyright" (2021). Faculty Scholarship at Penn Law. 2041.
Developmental Psychology Commons, Intellectual Property Law Commons, Law and Philosophy Commons, Law and Psychology Commons, Other Philosophy Commons, Personality and Social Contexts Commons, Philosophy of Language Commons, Philosophy of Mind Commons, Property Law and Real Estate Commons, Science and Technology Law Commons